The Pagan Experience prompt for this week: How do you define “humanity”?
What is your contribution to the collective space of humanity? How does your
spiritual path support this definition and contributions? - http://thepaganexperience.com/2015/02/feb-2-wk-1humanity/
“It may help to understand human affairs to be clear that
most of the great triumphs and tragedies of history are caused, not by people
being fundamentally good or fundamentally bad, but by people being
fundamentally people.”
― Neil Gaiman, Good Omens: The Nice and Accurate Prophecies of Agnes Nutter, Witch
― Neil Gaiman, Good Omens: The Nice and Accurate Prophecies of Agnes Nutter, Witch
[I should note that while goodreads.com says this quote is
from Neil Gaiman - and it very well may be - this book was written by both Neil
Gaiman and Terry Pratchett. So it could have been written collaboratively or by
Terry Pratchett. Or, perhaps goodreads has secret knowledge about who wrote
which parts, and therefore knows that Neil Gaiman wrote this particular bit. This seems unlikely to me.]
Humanity, literally, is all members of homo sapiens.
Metaphorically, humanity is whatever we want it to be.
Metaphors are tools, after all. Very malleable tools.
The idea that humanity - members of our species, that is -
has something that is uniquely ours in the animal kingdom, and that this thing
raises us above other animals morally, is so longstanding that it has shaped
our language since... well, how old is the English word 'humane'? How about the same meaning in other languages?
Humane means to treat kindly, respectfully, or with mercy.
Compassion is, supposedly, what makes us better than other apes. Except that
other animals show compassion too, and sometimes better than we do. Perhaps
altruism... no, that isn't it either. Altruistic behaviors have been observed
in many other species.
Hmmm. Well, what is unique about us? Perhaps
if we get away from concepts that categorize us as morally superior, we'll find
something.
We're not the only ones who use tools or language (other primates, and corvids, come to mind immediately).
We're not the only ones who have sex for fun or for companionship (lots of animals - no really, it's not just bonobos).
We're not even the only ones who engage in organized warfare
(chimps do that).
As far as I can tell, the only thing exclusive to our
species is the development of advanced technology (as opposed to simple tools).
So if we really wanted to be accurate (which we don't - humans aren't big on
accuracy), "humane" would mean something about figuring out tricky
sciency things, to include philosophical pursuits and, of
course, bureaucracies. (Obviously bureaucracies are symbolic of our innate
tendency toward cruelty. That, or our distrust of strangers. Take your pick.)
"Obviously bureaucracies are symbolic of our innate tendency toward cruelty. That, or our distrust of strangers."
ReplyDeleteThis made me snort! Well done. I like your literal and ever so slightly humorous take. I also heartily agree - we aren't different or superior than the rest of the animal kingdom. For all we know, gorillas and dolphins have whole religions and spiritual experiences that we will never know. Either way, we're all made of stars.